News Business Sports Travel Entertainment Homes Jobs Cars Shopping Place ads Newspaper services
chicagotribune.com

84° F
Latest forecast

E-mail this story
Printable format
Search archives


Most e-mailed
(last 24 hours)
Citadel turns chaos into cash
South rising in real estate
Blueprint for disaster
Fields of relics get new set of digs
Character at whose expense?
More from today
Past week



Hurricane Katrina

To readers | Fund list

On the Web

How to help animals

Photo gallery

Relief flows in
Relief flows in

Hurricane Katrina: The toll on animals
Hurricane Katrina: The toll on animals

Hurricane Katrina: Evacuees arrive in Illinois
Hurricane Katrina: Evacuees arrive in Illinois

Hurricane Katrina: Wright-Sullivan gems gutted
Hurricane Katrina: Wright-Sullivan gems gutted

Katrina's aftermath
Katrina's aftermath

After the storm
After the storm

Hurricane Katrina
Hurricane Katrina

Graphic

How a pump works

Damaged levees

Interactive

Flooding Simulation  Flash

Path of destruction  Flash

Demographic data  Flash

Videos

Victims react
Rozas returns to La.
Schmich in N. Orleans
Baton Rouge scene
Martinez in N. Orleans
Relief efforts
New Orleans zoo
Week 1

Eyewitness accounts

Mary Schmich in New Orleans
Martinez on victims
Witt in New Orleans
Glanton in Biloxi



  Hello, Ki | Subscribers: Get the Advantage | log out
Search:
chicagotribune

chicagotribune.com >> Nation/World

GULF COAST CRISIS: LANGUAGE DEBATE
Partner - Unclaimed Property
Some take offense at `refugees'

By Lolly Bowean
Tribune staff reporter
Published September 8, 2005

As Maywood resident Linda Dodson watched the coverage of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, she was stung by a word being used to describe people forced from their homes.

Although the strict definition of "refugee" applies when describing those fleeing the storm and floods, its connotation was offensive, Dodson said.

"It made me feel that these survivors were being looked down upon," she said. "When you think of refugees, you picture people swarming into another country. Instead of labeling them refugees, we should call them survivors."

Dodson isn't alone in objecting to use of "refugee." Jesse Jackson and members of the Congressional Black Caucus have criticized its use. And on Tuesday, President Bush said evacuees should be referred to as American citizens.

The use of the term refugees has stirred debate in cafes, offices and universities.

Susan Gzesh, director of the Human Rights Program at the University of Chicago, said it is easy to understand the debate because Americans never have had to examine the meaning of the word "refugee."

"It's the first time we've had people forced into this type of situation where they had to flee and have nothing," she said. "Maybe this will give us a better understanding of people who are refugees."

The word is offensive because it implies that U.S. citizens made homeless by the storm are not recognized by their home country, said Melissa Harris-Lacewell, a professor of political science at the University of Chicago's Center for the Study of Race, Politics and Culture.

"The reason the language is so inaccurate and racist is for the victims of this tragedy, it suggests they are asking something from a government that is not their own," she said.

The definition of "refugee" is someone who has fled his home, seeking help from another government, so it's appropriate in this case, said Marissa Graciosa, a spokeswoman for the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights.

She said the word typically isn't considered an insult.

"The spirit of the word reflects on all of us," she said. "It tells us that we are obligated to take care of these people."

----------

lbowean@tribune.com





Copyright © 2005, Chicago Tribune





Site index
News
Local news
Nation/World news
Opinion
Columnists
Special reports
Obituaries
Health
Education
Weather
Traffic
Business
Your money
Stocks
The Digital Page
What's ahead
Business tech
Technology
Wireless & Networking
Columnists
Sports
Bears
Bulls
Blackhawks
Cubs
White Sox
Colleges
High school
Golf
Soccer
Columnists
Travel
Flight tracker
Domestic fares
International fares
Travel deals
Midwest getaways
Resourceful traveler
10 for the road
GeoQuiz
Entertainment
Arts
Dining
Critics' reviews
Movies
Music
Theater
Shopping
Television
Today's paper
In the community
Registration
Subscription
Contact us
What's in it for you?
Classified
Find a job
Find a car
Find real estate
Find an apartment
Shopping
Find a mortgage
Dating
Pets
Place an ad
How to advertise
metromix.com |  ChicagoSports.com |  Subscriber Advantage  |  Site tour |  Privacy Policy |  Terms of Service
House - Content Promotion